There would be an ontological difference between god and one of. Barnett newmans critique of pictorial ontology and spinozas monism. Immanence and ontological participation in kaprow, deleuze. Figure 1 below represents spinoza s taxonomy of the infinite. A source book in mathematical logic, 18791931 edited by jean van heijenoort fg. The ethics, by baruch spinoza free ebook global grey. Lulu the book is available in printed format and as pdf file. While it is infinitely superior to read the book in its entirety, a handful of chapters are candidates for skimming if one is pressed for time or feeling overwhelmed. Spinoza s ethics is one of the most remarkable, important, and difficult books in the history of philosophy. Shared attributes and the basis of spinoza s monism della rocca, spinoza s substance monism september 27.
Spinozas metaphysics fall 2017 columbia university. Spinoza can define god as a substance 1, definition 6 but the actual existence of god as a substance does not follow from the mere definition of god as a substance. However, spinoza attributes all determination to one substance. Proposition 11 of part 1 of spinoza s ethics states that god necessarily exists. Spinozas ontological argument for the existence of god. Except god, no substance can be or be conceived, and the corollary claims that god is unique, that is, by d6 that in nature there is only one. Although his demonstration of the proposition is often said to constitute his ontological argument for the existence of god, and to report an essentially private rational perception of gods existence, he provides four distinct proofs for the proposition. The role and the distinction can be more easily conceived if we have a look. Mental hindrances from words and from the popular confusion of ready imagination with distinct understanding. Modern philosophy professor geoff pynn northern illinois university spring 2016 in this handout well look at a fairly simple interpretation of spinoza s argument for substance monism.
The ethical significance of substancegod difference in. Deleuzes neoleibnizianism, events and the logic of. Hampshires recent, posthumously published, book spinoza and spinozism. In propositions one through fifteen of part one, spinoza presents the basic. Thus the work will give full material and indications for the original study of one of the greatest exponents of christian doctrine. It is then argued that the characterization here proposed provides a good account of anselms and descartes proof, but shows that there is no ontological proof in spinoza. The ethics, by baruch spinoza free ebook global grey ebooks. Boehm shows that spinoza s position is responsible for one of the ways in which the antinomies of reason are generated, and in addition, that spinoza has resources to circumvent their results. By showing how spinoza s arguments rely on the psr, i hope to demonstrate its centrality to spinoza s thinking with respect to the important case of. Religious and secular authorities saw it as a threat to faith, social and political harmony, and everyday morality, and its author was almost universally regarded as.
Spinoza s philosophy of religion is largely contained in the theologicopolitical treatise. Spinozas arguments for the existence of god request pdf. One can think of it as an extended comparison of spinoza s essences with the scholastics substantial forms. Garrett, spinoza s ontological argument garrett, ethics ip5. In that work he argues for the view that we should interpret scripture solely on its own terms by carefully studying it, not with any concepts or doctrines that cannot themselves be derived from the text. Taking the lead from kants critique of ontological arguments in the critique of pure reason, the paper explores the underlying ontological and epistemological. Spinoza s theoretical philosophy is one of the most radical attempts to construct a pure ontology with a single infinite substance. The common structure of religion, philosophy and politics. His ethics is an ethology, rather than a moral science. Weexaminethepossibilityofapplyingknowledgerepresen. Spinoza s precursor descartes ideas on modal metaphysics are not very elaborate. The argument is in a line of development that goes back to anselm of canterbury 10331109. Baruch spinoza s philosophy encompasses nearly every area of philosophical discourse, including metaphysics, epistemology, political philosophy, ethics, philosophy of mind, and philosophy of science. In the first part, i discuss the nature of spinoza s radical ethics.
But spinoza, of course, had every reason to be impressed, for leibnizs contribution to the history of the ontological. The true intellectual system of the universe london. Once spinoza establishes steps 1 and 2,the rest of the proof pretty much follows from. With his mindbody dualism and advocacy of the free will, his doctrine that the world is created by gods free will differs clearly from spinoza s and offers several questions. This article is a reconstruction of spinoza s materialist ontology using deleuzes philosophy, towards a revolutionary ethics of desire. Spinozas modal ontological argument for monism one of spinoza s clearest expressions of his monism is ethics i p14, and its corollary 1. Nancy levene connects the theologicopolitical and philosophical projects through their common ethical concern. Godels ontological proof is a formal argument by the mathematician kurt godel 19061978 for the existence of god. The thesis examines the linkage between ontology and politics in spinoza, and considers the extent to which his philosophy discloses novel materialist. Nancy levene connects the theologicopolitical and philosophical projects.
It discusses wolfsons analysis of the proof and argues that his characterization is not mistaken but insufficient. Kant, spinoza, and the metaphysics of the ontological. A decade before writing the ethics, spinoza gave an argument for ontological unity that differs greatly from the a priori reasoning found in the ethics. In attempting to remain as faithful as possible to spinoza s project, there is a degree of complexity and obscurity that cannot be avoided. In spinoza s usage, the noun affect is a very broad term that covers all the emotions but also some dispositions or charactertraits such as cowardice and greed. Boehm interprets the antinomies in the critique of pure reason as evidence that kant aims exclusively to refute spinoza, so that the critique of reason just is a critique of spinozism pp. Spinoza conatus ethics ontology god substance introduction in the following paper i will present an argument that puts forward one possible explanation of the role of the god and the god substance relation in the first book of spinoza s ethics.
This paper provides an interpretation and evaluation of spinoza s highly original version of the ontological proof in terms of the concept of substance instead of the concept of perfection in the first book of his ethics. Spinoza s ontological argument don garrett j reposition xi of part i of spinoza s ethics is the claim that god or substance consisting of infinite attributes, each of which expresses eternal and infinite essence, necessarily exists. Treatise on theology and politics early modern texts. Finite modes and individuation garrett nyu, 5 washington place, room 202, 11. Corresponding to each of the kinds of infinity are distinct ontological, temporal, and spatial categories. If we are to believe leibniz, spinoza found the argument sound. While spinoza, the godintoxicated man, might be commonly associated with the belief in a single great ground of being, he was not concerned solely with the great and powerful. Immanuel kants critique of descartess ontological argument 66 appendix a.
Anselms ontological argument, in its most succinct form, is as follows. When it appeared in 1670, baruch spinoza s theologicalpolitical treatise was denounced as the most dangerous book ever publishedgodless, full of abominations, a book forged in hell by the devil himself. This book has 217 pages in the pdf version, and was originally published in 1667. See wolfgang bartuschat, the ontological basis of spinoza s theory of politics, in spinoza s political and theological thought, ed. Spinoza s proof of substance monism philosophy 322. Spinoza s proof shows only that the attribute of a substance must be conceivedthroughthissubstance. In philosophical jargon, a feature of the essence of god is said to be existence. For example, things infinite by cause are the modes, which possess duration and quantity. In other words, the ontological unity spinoza inserted at the heart of his mature philosophy was consistent with what he observed as a younger man studying nature. Spinoza 163277 is a philosopher of the seventeenth. By neglecting spinoza s non ontological arguments, commentators have contributed to this failure to fully appreciate the importance of the psr to spinoza s system.
Both aristotle and spinoza equate entity with determination. In philosophy it is customary to consider an argument and give reasons for accepting or rejecting it in part or wholly. Valtteri viljanens spinoza s geometry of power approaches spinoza s metaphysics from a different direction, focusing instead on his view of essences. Pdf realism and ontology in spinoza, abelard and deleuze. Chubb in this paper i have approached spinoza s arguments for the existence of god from a somewhat unusual angle. And so spinoza limits himself to a literal reading of the bible, which is nothing. Baruch spinozas philosophy encompasses nearly every area of philosophical discourse. Kind of infinity ontological level temporal properties spatial properties. Baruch spinoza and rene descartes employed versions of the ontological argument where the very concept of god as a perfect being implies existence as a property. Spinoza and the ontological proof oxford scholarship. Pdf barnett newman as implicit interpreter of spinozas substance monism find. Kant, spinoza, and the metaphysics of the ontological proof.
This book, which presents spinoza s main ideas in dictionary form, has as its subject the opposition between ethics and morality, and the link between ethical and ontological propositions. Part 1 of 2 this is a version of spinoza s ontological argument. In this book, omri boehm rigorously and engagingly argues that they indeed represent a spinozistic threat. British journal for the history of philosophy steven nadler, professor of philosophy at the university of wisconsinmadison has written a thoroughly engaging study of a book which, not only controversial in its day, may be. The roots of spinozas metaphysics and philosophy of god. This realist reading of the ontological argument which informs 17 a. So perhaps the best reason for reading spinoza s ethics is this. Earle, 1951, the ontological argument in spinoza, philosophy and phenomenological research, 4, 550 18 ibid. All things that are, are either in themselves or in something else. Ethics and freedom within spinozas system of necessary. Those three features of superstition pretty clearly rule out the theory that it consists in a confused idea of god. Those three features of superstition pretty clearly rule out the theory that it consists in a confused idea. In the argument above, he has assumed what he needs to prove.
For this purpose, we use the axioms and propositions in the. This paper attempts to characterize the ontological proof for the existence of god. A comprehension of spinozas god through the dichotomy of. But spinoza, of course, had every reason to be impressed, for leibnizs contribution to the history of the ontological argument was significant. Its objective, rather, is to probe the particular connections between the ontological proof and the causa sui. Spinozas ontological argument for the existence of god, part. Spinoza himself avoids giving strict definitions or a surplus of examples indeed, he gives remarkably few and for that reason i avoid giving technical terms a rigorous and concrete definition. His proof for god follows a similar structure as descartes ontological argument.
Spinoza employs four proofs to establish this important. Chapters two and three form the heart of boehms book. Spinozas philosophy is largely contained in two books. Dogmatism has no place in this endeavor as spinoza has clearly argued. Samuel shirley, who translated spinoza s complete works into english, summed. Practical philosophy and arne naess article spinoza an. One concept which can be saved from ambiguity through this methodology is the infinite. Description considered one of the great rationalists of 17thcentury philosophy, spinoza s posthumous masterpiece ethics, in which he opposed descartess mindbody dualism, has earned him recognition as one of western.
Wellequipped peers are openminded peers who look both outward and inward. The common structure of religion, philosophy and politics in. Spinoza scholar genevieve lloyd, the study of spinoza is crucial when we explore the idea that we are part of nature lloyd, 1994, p. Professor grossman effectively argues for the existence of the spinozistic god from an ana. Baruch spinoza s philosophy encompasses nearly every area of philosophical discourse. God, by definition, is that for which no greater can be conceived. For this purpose, we use the axioms and propositions in the first book of spinozas ethics as knowledge base and a tableaubased satisfiability tester as reasoner. It earned spinoza an enduring reputation as one of the most important and original thinkers of the seventeenth century. Rationality as well as spirituality, wilber, spinoza and. Modes are on the next rung of spinozas ontological ladder. Spinoza s notion of acquiescence, in that it is conceived amid the ambiguous ontological logos of substance i. Ei ii, iii, iv, v for ethics, part i roman numerals refer to the.
165 1769 1226 1638 1339 1506 1499 1161 735 184 475 611 573 582 1479 1242 777 1039 1495 1701 1072 7 13 293 1760 404 115 869